Halloween on the lake: the Monster Mash, the Scarecrow Bash, and October nights on this land since 1873 | 257 Methodist Park Ln

Lake life

Halloween on the lake: the Monster Mash, the Scarecrow Bash, and October nights on this land since 1873

By Vic & Amy Petrenko · The Petrenko Group · · 8 min read
Historic white farmhouse porch at dusk on Halloween with a glowing carved jack-o'-lantern beside white columns and a lake glinting in the twilight
The porch has kept this evening for 153 years: first by lantern light, now with a carved pumpkin for every generation.

October on Lake Hartwell is a month of carved pumpkins and costume parades: the Scarecrow Bash lines downtown with decorated scarecrows all month, the Mayor's Monster Mash turns Railroad Street Park into an open-air costume party for Hartwell's children, and state parks from Victoria Bryant to Baker Creek run hayrides and haunted trails through the last two weekends. The family at 257 Methodist Park Lane has kept this month on the same high ground since 1873, and the way it is kept now, with electricity and a lake at the foot of the lawn, is only the newest version of a very old October.

The month downtown

The Scarecrow Bash runs the length of October, dressing downtown Hartwell's streets in scarecrow after scarecrow, each one put together by a local family, a classroom, or a business. It is a month-long art show made of hay and flannel, and it does what every Hartwell festival does: it gives the town a reason to walk the square, wave at neighbors, and let the season change at walking pace. Then, as the scarecrows reach their last week, the Mayor's Monster Mash brings the month to its big night, a free afternoon of trick-or-treating, games, and costume prizes at Railroad Street Park that organizers schedule for Halloween itself, from 4 to 6 in the evening. Check the city's calendar as the date nears, as it is always worth confirming, but the tradition is as dependable as the scarecrows.

Around the lake, the parks lean in their own way. Victoria Bryant State Park, about fifteen miles from Hartwell, hosts its Haunted Evenings with a hayride, a haunted trail, campsite decorating, and costume contests on October 23-24 and again October 30-31. On the South Carolina side, Baker Creek State Park holds its Boo!-ker Creek, a Halloween-themed 5K, on October 23. Put it together and the last two weekends of the month give every lake family the same offer: a hayride one night, a costume run the next, and the town's big party in between. The season is not quiet. It has simply learned to be fun.

View from the covered porch at 257 Methodist Park Lane across the flat lawn toward Lake Hartwell on a clear day
The same porch, every October: the view out across the flat lawn has been the stage for a century and a half of autumn nights.

The October this land kept before the lake

There was no Monster Mash in the 1870s, and for a long time there was no electricity either. October on the high ground above the Savannah River was a working month first: the last of the corn in, sweet potatoes dug, the woodpile built high, and the pecans coming on in the grove that still shades the estate today. When the days shortened, the family sat on the porch by lantern light, and the stories that came out in the dark were the old ones, the kind every farm family told: the strange light in the bottomlands, the sound that carried across the river, the neighbor who had seen something. October was when the valley felt its own mystery, and the porch was where you told about it together.

Candles in carved gourds and pumpkins arrived as the custom did, a harvest face lit from inside, and the children of the house made the rounds of the lane, trading a song or a story for a treat from the kitchen. The church on the lane, the same one whose name the road still carries, kept its own October rhythms, and the family at 257 walked them as their neighbors did. It was not the polished production downtown runs now, but the bones were the same: a darkening month, a porch, a carved light, and a community that made sure its children had a reason to smile in the dark.

The same ground, a new kind of evening

Today the month at 257 Methodist Park Lane runs on a fuller stage. The flat lawn that was once a working yard is big enough for a gathering of any size, the lakeside pavilion with its two full bathrooms hosts costume dinners and bonfire company, and the covered porch still does what it always did: holds the family while the evening comes on. The lake at the foot of the property adds its own October theater, the Hunter's Moon rising over open water on October 26, boats decked out for their last runs of the season, and the quiet that settles once the boats leave and the pecan harvest takes over the rhythm.

What has not changed is the point of the month. October was always when this land turned inward, gathered its people close, and reminded itself, by lantern light or porch light, that the dark is friendlier in company. The Scarecrow Bash and the Monster Mash are the town doing in public what this porch has done in private for 153 years. A family that buys 257 Methodist Park Lane will not just inherit a house. It will inherit the best seat for the season, four and a half flat acres of it, with a town that knows how to celebrate the month and a porch that has been keeping it since before the dam.